From Blueprints To Betrayal: The Daring, And Downfall, Of A Cold War Spy
It was the middle of the Cold War and the CIA was having a difficult time getting information on what the Soviet Union was up to next.
The agency needed a spy — a Russian spy — who was willing to go the full way and betray his country.
It found one in Adolf Tolkachev, a Soviet aviation expert.
David Hoffman tells Tolkachev's story in his new book, The Billion Dollar Spy.
"He married a young woman at his institute, his top-secret military institute, and her parents had been purged by Stalin," Hoffman tells NPR's Arun Rath. "She grew up an orphan. He inherited her rage at what that system had done."
That rage motivated Tolkachev to risk his life in a society that was suspicious of anyone who associated with foreigners. He met his CIA handlers in person; it was extremely risky work. And according to Hoffman, he became one of the most important spies of the Cold War.
To hear the full conversation, click the audio link above.
Interview Highlights
On Tolkachev's old-fashioned spycraft
The CIA had to think of a lot of ways to communicate with him safely and to meet him on the street. ... Oftentimes the big issue was: How could he copy a lot of secret documents? There were no photocopiers he could use because they were all under lock and key.
So Tolkachev devised a very low tech approach. He put the documents in his coat pocket and he walked out of that top-secret institute at the lunch hour back to his apartment, which was a 20-minute walk, and he took out a camera and he photographed the pages and then he went back to work and put them back in the file. And he did this for years.
On the value of the intelligence Tolkachev provided
For many, many years the CIA had a hard time penetrating the Soviet Union and especially trying to divine what was going on in the minds of its leaders. A lot of people said the CIA had absolutely no idea what was going on, but the Tolkachev case opens a window on a different kind of spying that was very valuable to the U.S. military. ...
The big question about the Soviets in the middle of the Cold War was capabilities — what could they do — and what were their intentions. And Tolkachev provided blueprints, documents, plans that showed not only the current capabilities of Soviet aviation and radars but also showed what was being planned for 10 years ahead. And this was a windfall, because [the CIA] could see what the Soviets were gonna do, how their radars worked, how their planes communicated with each other — and develop countermeasures 10 years ahead.
On how Tolkachev was betrayed, leading to his execution by the Soviets
There was a young man who was being trained to be Tolkachev's handler. The year this man was being trained, he didn't do very well and eventually he had to take a required lie detector test, and the young man flunked the test. And when that happened the CIA decided he was not gonna go to Moscow to handle their best agent — he was gonna be fired. ...
His name was Edward Lee Howard, and the CIA fired him, and they kind of pushed him out the door, and he was angry. He decided to get even with the CIA and to betray Tolkachev, and then he became the first serving CIA officer to defect to the Soviet Union.
On Tolkachev's legacy, and why he's not better-known
This case has been secret for many years and although ... bits and pieces [have] come out, in this book I got the CIA to declassify to me more than 900 pages of the operational cables about how it was carried out. So I think that this is one of the most important spies of the Cold War, but until now [he] has been largely held in secret.
The lesson of the Tolkachev case is that you can focus all you want on high-tech satellites, you can tap into people's email, but in the end, despite all the changes in technology, having a great human source is absolutely invaluable.
9(MDE1MTIxMDg0MDE0MDQ3NTY3MzkzMzY1NA001))
Transcript
ARUN RATH, HOST:
It was the middle of the Cold War. The CIA was desperate for information on what the Soviet Union was up to. They needed a Russian spy, one willing to go the full way and betray his country. In "The Billion Dollar Spy," David Hoffman tells the unknown story of the man who fit the bill - Adolph Tolkachev.
DAVID HOFFMAN: Tolkachev had this great sense of disenchantment and anger. He married a young woman at his institute - his top-secret military Institute - and her parents had been purged by Stalin. Her mother was hauled old out of her apartment, taken away, tried and shot. Her father - sent away to a camp for more than decade. She was two years old when that happened. She grew up an orphan. He inherited her rage at what that system had done.
RATH: That rage motivated Tolkachev to seek out the CIA. Now that espionage is defined by hackers stealing information electronically, it's almost shocking to read about a human risking his life, handling actual documents and arranging in-person, clandestine meetings.
HOFFMAN: Well, this was the hardest option for the CIA -right? - to meet a guy on the street. You could endanger his life with one false move. So the CIA had to think up a lot of ways to communicate with him safely and to meet him on the street, and they did that. And often times, the big issue was - how could he copy a lot of secret documents? There were no photocopiers he could use because they were all under lock and key. So Tolkachev devised a very low-tech approach. He put the documents in his coat pocket, and he walked out of the topic-secret institute at the lunch hour, back to his apartment, which was a 20-minute walk. And he took out a camera, and he photographed the pages. And then he went back to work and put them back in the file.
RATH: (Laughter).
HOFFMAN: And he did this for years.
RATH: Can you have is a sense of the value of the intelligence Tolkachev provided? How did it actually affect U.S. military policy, diplomacy, other things?
HOFFMAN: For many, many years, the CIA had a high time penetrating the Soviet Union and especially trying to divine what was going on in the minds of its leaders. A lot of people said the CIA had absolutely no idea what was going on. But the Tolkachev case opens a window on a different kind of spying that was very valuable to the U.S. military 'cause the big question about the Soviets in the middle of the Cold War were capabilities. What could they do, and what were their intentions? And Tolkachev provided blueprints, documents, plans that showed not only the current capabilities of Soviet aviation and radars, but also showed what was being planned for 10 years ahead. And this was a windfall because they could see what the Soviets were going to do, how their radars worked, how their planes communicated with each other and develop countermeasures 10 years ahead.
RATH: So he provides this amazing edge for the U.S., but his story, of course, does not end well for him. He's ultimately betrayed. Can you explain how his story came to an end?
HOFFMAN: There was a young man who was being trained to be Tolkachev's handler. The year this man was being trained, he didn't do very well. And eventually, he had to take a required lie detector test, and the young man flunked the test. And when that happened, the CIA decided he was not going to go to Moscow to handle their best agent. He was going to be fired. And his name was Edward Lee Howard, and the CIA fired him. And he was angry. He decided to get even with the CIA and to betray Tolkachev. And then he became the first serving CIA officer to defect to the Soviet Union.
RATH: When we think about very well-known names of, you know, spies - double agents - in the Cold War, it doesn't seem that Tolkachev is very well known. Even Edward Howard, the guy who was responsible for him getting turned in, seems like - that his name is more familiar. Why do you think maybe he's not as well-known?
HOFFMAN: Well, in this case, it's been secret for many years. There have been bits and pieces come out. In this book, I got the CIA to declassify to me more than 900 pages of the operational cables about how it was carried out. So I think that this is one of the most of Cold War, but until now, it's been largely held in secret. The lesson of the Tolkachev case is that you can focus all you want on high-tech satellites, you can tap into people's email, but in the end, despite all the changes in technology, having a great human source is absolutely invaluable.
RATH: David Hoffman is a contributing editor at The Washington Post and a correspondent for PBS "Frontline." His new book, "The Billion Dollar Spy: A True Story Of Cold War Espionage And Betrayal," is out on Tuesday. David, thanks very much.
HOFFMAN: Thank you, Arun. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
300x250 Ad
300x250 Ad