Indian Government Blocks, Then Quickly Unblocks Porn Sites
India is an ancient, traditional country. It's also a democracy that's very modern when it comes to the Internet and technology.
That's one reason the country sometimes sends mixed messages like this: Publishing or distributing pornography in print or on the Web is illegal in India. But viewing it is not.
With this in mind, lawyer Vijay Panjwani argued before the Supreme Court last month that pornography should be blocked as broadly as possible.
"Pornography is a criminal activity from A to Z. Completely!" he says.
But even he acknowledged that abolishing it is impossible given India's huge Internet use and the widespread presence of smartphones.
"A 20-year-old has a mobile phone, a 9-year-old has a mobile. Who's going to stop them?" he asks.
For a few days this past week it appeared the government was on his side.
In one of the biggest dragnets of its kind, India's Telecommunications Ministry ordered Internet providers to block more than 850 sites.
Most were pornographic. But those swept up in the directive included CollegeHumor.com, which tends toward the sophomoric and the raunchy, though not pornographic.
Pranesh Prakash, policy director of the Center for Internet and Society, obtained the list of sites that had been kept secret and then published the list online.
"And until I did that, no one knew what all had been blocked," Prakash says. "The government was essentially arguing until that point that it was blocking only child pornography. And we saw that that was not true."
An Indian Christian woman holds a placard denouncing pornography at a protest rally in Bangalore in August 2014.
Social Media Lambasts Government
The government directive sparked a raging debate on social media in which Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government was accused of censorship and scorned for playing nanny to the nation.
It didn't take long for #NewBanIdea to spring to life and Indian irreverence to run wild.
"Ban tax collection," tweeted Parikshit Joshi and "corruption will end."
Sandhya Naidu tweeted, "Land of Kamasutra, too much nudity on some of your sculptures ... Do something, please."
"Let's ban everything and become North Korea," added Harpreet Bhatia.
In the face of the barrage, the government on Wednesday relented and lifted the ban for all sites except those engaging in child pornography.
This move left feminists such as Ranjana Kumari distressed. The adult site Pornhub.com ranks India as one of the world' most prolific consumers of pornography. And much of it, Kumari says, is about eroticizing the subjugation of women.
"Why ban only child porn?" she says.
Stand-up comics, on the other hand, were relishing the new material.
Comedian Anuvab Pal joked that the government reversed itself to indulge its core supporters.
"A large number of voting base are young men who want economic development, strong government, but they are also large consumers of pornography," he says with a laugh. "And that's the base they don't want to alienate. I think they realize it."
9(MDE1MTIxMDg0MDE0MDQ3NTY3MzkzMzY1NA001))
Transcript
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
India is an ancient, traditional country. It's also a democracy with a huge population using the Internet. And there's been a big debate there over access to pornography, with some accusing the government of acting like moral police. Well, today, the government restored access to nearly 1,000 adult and humor websites it had banned just four days ago. From New Delhi, NPR's Julie McCarthy reports.
JULIE MCCARTHY, BYLINE: Publishing or distributing pornography in print or on the web is illegal in India. Viewing is not, says Supreme Court lawyer Vijay Panjwani. But in his opinion...
VIJAY PANJWANI: Pornography is a criminal activity from A to Z, completely.
MCCARTHY: Panjwani argued the case before the Supreme Court last month, seeking to block pornography as broadly as possible. A ban, he says, is impossible given the growing number of Indians using the Internet and smartphones.
PANJWANI: Mobile phones - 20-year-old has mobile phone. Ninety-year-old has mobile phone. Who's going to stop them?
MCCARTHY: You feel that somehow this has a corrosive effect on society.
PANJWANI: Yes. I definitely feel.
MCCARTHY: For a few days this week, it appeared the government agreed with him. In one of the biggest dragnets of its kind, India's Telecommunications Ministry ordered Internet providers to block over 850 sites. Swept up in the directive were even sites like collegehumor.com. Pranesh Prakash, policy director for the Center for Internet and Society, obtained the list of sites that had been kept secret from a whistleblower and published the list himself online.
PRANESH PRAKASH: Until I did that, no one knew what all had been blocked. The government was essentially arguing until that point that it was only blocking child pornography, and we saw that that was not true.
MCCARTHY: The Internet mandate sparked a raging debate on social media where the government was scorned for playing nanny to the nation and accused of Internet censorship. #NewBanIdea sprang to life, and Indian irreverence reigned. Ban tax collection, tweeted Parikshit Joshi, and corruption will end. Twitterer Sandhya Naidu wrote, land of Kamasutra, too much nudity on some of your sculptures. Do something, please. Shirish Kunder tweeted about Modi's pet manufacturing project. Forget make in India; now we can't even shake in India. Under the embarrassing barrage, the government relented and lifted the ban for all sites except those engaging in child pornography.
This move left feminists such as Ranjana Kumari distressed. The adult site pornhub.com ranks India as one of the world's most prolific users of pornography, and much of it, Kumari says, is about eroticizing the subjugation of women. Why, she asks, ban only child porn? Stand-up comics, on the other hand, were lapping up the new material. Comedian Anuvab Pal joked, the government reversed itself to indulge its core supporters.
ANUVAB PAL: A large number of their voting base are young men who want economic development, strong government. But they're also large consumers of pornography. So, you know, that's a base you don't want to alienate, I think they realize.
MCCARTHY: Julie McCarthy, NPR News, New Delhi. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
300x250 Ad
300x250 Ad