A Place To Reflect During Jewish Holy Days — That's Not A Temple
Judaism, like most religions, operates in the moral and ethical choices that happen every single day, but there are also times set aside for really digging deep, like the Days of Awe, a 10-day period that begins at sunset Wednesday. Sunset also marks the beginning of Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year.
"It's a kind of spiritual taking of stock, both regarding what we've done in the past and how we're going to proceed in the future," says Lawrence Schiffman, who teaches Judaic studies at New York University.
But for some modern Jews, sitting in temple isn't the best way in to that future. So some head online.
"I developed this idea for a project called 10Q, which would be 10 questions through an online interface, as a way of guided introspection," says writer Ben Greenman, a member of a group that works to connect Jewish traditions to modern life. When you sign up for 10Q, a question comes to your inbox during each of the Days of Awe asking about major milestones, regrets, hopes for the future.
"A lot of people, as they answer them, do really take it in an ethical direction, and then some people say, 'Oh, I really got taken on interest rates, and I should have waited two more months to buy the house,' " he says.
However you answer the questions, after the 10 days end, the online form disappears. And then, a year later, your answers are emailed back.
"I'm forced to look at the places where I've really grown away from where I was a year ago when I chose to put this thing on paper, and the places where I'm really, really consistent," says Libby Lenkinski, one of the more than 20,000 participants.
"It's about finding points of access that then people can expand on, and I think that's true for people who have no background or education in Judaism, and for people like me, who do and still haven't always found those particular inroads," she says.
Schiffman likes the online aspect of 10Q. But he thinks the questions like "Describe an event in the world that has impacted you this year" are missing the full richness of Jewish thought.
"Improve yourself and your life? This is great. But I still believe that needs to be talked about in moral and ethical ways," he says. "So much of it is oriented not on ethical and religious and spiritual questions about ourselves, but on things that are either out of our control or things that are in our control and are very nice and very important, but they don't have to do with the spiritual sense of the holidays."
Although they're not traditional, those sorts of questions can be paths into deeper places, Greenman says.
"Asking people what you did wrong, I feel like I would get worse answers — more defensive answers, or more pat answers — rather than this kind of exploration, where maybe it starts a little bit more open-ended and simpler but then gives people ownership of it," he says.
And with that ownership, 10Q participants can use the questions to really reflect on their lives, and the path they want to follow — during the Days of Awe and the whole new year.
9(MDE1MTIxMDg0MDE0MDQ3NTY3MzkzMzY1NA001))
Transcript
AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:
Sunset tonight marks the start of Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year and the start of the Days of Awe. This 10-day-period, ending on Yom Kippur, is a time when observant Jews reflect on the past year. And as Deena Prichep reports, some Jews are taking this reflection out of the temple and onto their tablets.
DEENA PRICHEP, BYLINE: Judaism, like most religions, operates in the moral and ethical choices that happen every single day. But there are also times set aside for really digging deep, times like the Days of Awe, when the very gates of heaven are said to swing open.
LAWRENCE SCHIFFMAN: Those days are open for two reasons. On the one hand, they're open because God on high wants us to go through this process. But on the other hand they're open because we've opened ourselves to them.
PRICHEP: Lawrence Schiffman teaching Judaic studies at New York University.
SCHIFFMAN: It's a kind of a spiritual taking of stock. Both regarding what we've done in the past and how we're going to precede in the future.
PRICHEP: But for some modern Jews sitting in Temple isn't the best way into that future.
BEN GREENMAN: I developed this idea for a project called 10Q, which would be 10 questions through an online interface, as a way of guided introspection.
PRICHEP: Writer Ben Greenman is a member of Reboot, a group that works to create Jewish traditions to modern life. When you sign up for 10Q a question comes to your inbox during each of the Days of Awe, asking about major milestones, regrets, hopes for the future.
GREENMAN: A lot of people as they answer them do really take it in an ethical direction and then some people say, oh I really got taken on interest rates and I should have waited two more months to buy the house.
PRICHEP: However you answer the questions, after the 10 days end the online forum disappears and then, a year later, your answers are e-mailed back.
LIBBY LENKINSKI: It means that I'm forced to look at the places where I've really grown away from where I was a year ago, when I chose to put this thing on paper and the places where I'm really, really consistent.
PRICHEP: Libby Lenkinski is one of the more than 20,000 participants.
LENKINSKI: It's about finding points of access that then people can expand on. And I think that's true for people who have no background or education in Judaism and for people like me who do and still haven't always found those particular inroads.
SCHIFFMAN: Improve yourself and your life - this is great. But I still believe that needs to be talked about in moral and ethical ways.
PRICHEP: Professors Lawrence Schiffman likes the online aspect of 10Q, but he thinks the questions like, describe an event in the world that has impacted you this year, are missing the full richness of Jewish thought.
SCHIFFMAN: So much of it is oriented, not on ethical and religious and spiritual questions about ourselves, but on things that are either out of our control or things that are in our control and are very nice and very important but they don't have to do with the spiritual sense of the holidays.
PRICHEP: But though not traditional, those sorts of questions can be paths into deeper places. Says 10Q founder Ben Greenman.
GREENMAN: Asking people what you did wrong, I feel like I would get worse answers, more defensive answers or more pat answers. Rather than this kind of exploration were maybe it starts a little bit more open ended and simpler, but then gives people ownership of it.
PRICHEP: And with that ownership 10Q participants can use the questions to really reflect on their lives and the paths they want to follow. During the Days of Awe and the whole New Year. For NPR News, I'm Deena Prichep. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
300x250 Ad
300x250 Ad