Teens Hoping For More Jobs, Higher Wages This Summer
Recipe for a good summer-job market: First, hire a lot of people in May. Second, give workers raises, and third, push down gasoline prices. Mix it all together — and pour out hope for teen workers.
"Having a job makes me feel really excited. I can put my own money in my pocket instead of asking my parents for money all the time," said José Moncada, a 16-year-old job seeker in New York City.
Moncada and other teens may have caught a break Friday when the economy followed that seasonal employment recipe precisely.
The Labor Department said employers added 280,000 new jobs in May, exceeding economists' expectations. May brought a burst of hiring in leisure and hospitality, with 57,000 new jobs. Retailers added 31,400 jobs.
Typically, those are the sectors that hire a lot of younger workers. And those are the sectors that benefit when workers have more cash to spend. The May jobs report showed average hourly earnings rose by 0.3 percent — which translates to an annual growth rate of nearly 4 percent, far exceeding inflation.
Here's another factor that may encourage summer hiring:
On Friday, OPEC announced it will keep oil production unchanged this year, even though supplies are plentiful. That helped lower the U.S. benchmark price to less than $58 a barrel, down from around $106 at this time last year.
AAA, the auto club, is predicting gasoline prices will fall this summer. The average national price of a gallon is $2.75, way down from $3.66 last year at this time. "This could be the year of the summer road trip," AAA spokeswoman Avery Ash said.
That's all positive for young workers. "Seasonal hiring is expected to take a nice jump this summer," according to a report from CareerBuilder, an online jobs site.
Based on a Harris survey of more than 2,000 hiring managers, the company concluded that 36 percent of private-sector employers will be hiring summer workers, up from 30 percent last year and an average of 21 percent from 2008-2011.
"Many summer jobs went away completely during the recession as companies eliminated internship programs and as households cut back on vacation and recreation spending," CareerBuilder CEO Matt Ferguson said in a statement.
Not only did many summer jobs disappear during the Great Recession, but competition increased for those that remained, according to professor Ruth Milkman, a labor expert at the City University of New York.
"It used to be that minimum-wage jobs were mostly for very young people, either teenagers or people just entering the labor market permanently," Milkman said. "What's happened with the deterioration of the wage structure in recent decades is that more and more working adults are in minimum wage jobs."
All of that competition has discouraged many teens from even looking for work. As recently as 2000, 52 percent of teenagers were in the labor force. Today, it's down to less than a third.
So here's where things stand heading into summer: The national unemployment rate is 5.5 percent, but for workers ages 16-19, it's 17.9 percent. That's much lower than the 27.2 percent peak most recently hit in 2010, but it's still painfully high.
And there's a big unknown in this summer's labor market. While the demand for workers has been growing, so have wages. At least 29 states and many cities have passed laws raising the minimum wage well above the federal minimum of $7.25 an hour. Many private employers, such as Wal-Mart, McDonald's and Target, have raised their wage floors to well above the federal minimum.
These wage increases will disproportionately affect young workers. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says more than half of all minimum-wage workers are 24 or younger.
So teens who do land jobs may make more money, which they could then spend at malls and restaurants and amusement parks. But their higher wages could dampen hiring.
Whether the bigger paychecks for young people will translate into a better economy — or just less hiring — remains to be seen.
For now, Moncada, the job seeker at the Henry Street Settlement on Manhattan's Lower East Side, just wants to get working. Last summer, he cleaned streets at the state minimum of $8.75 an hour. He wants the same gig this summer.
He said his family of six lives on less than $30,000 a year, so he needs money for his school uniform and sneakers. Also, "I go to the store to get food that we need for the house," he said.
9(MDE1MTIxMDg0MDE0MDQ3NTY3MzkzMzY1NA001))
Transcript
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
It's the season when hordes of college and high school students are looking for summer jobs. Reporter Kaomi Goetz spent some time this week talking with young people who want work, and she found it's still tough out there.
KAOMI GOETZ, BYLINE: A dreary chill settled over New York City earlier this week, making it a little hard to think about summer. But the weather didn't dampen the enthusiasm of 16-year-old Jose Moncada. He came to Manhattan's Lower East Side to the Henry Street Settlement to register for a summer job.
JOSE MONCADA: I'm in a program for GCB (ph), and they told us to - the told me to show you that.
UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: OK.
GOETZ: Moncada is filling out paperwork in the agency's gym. He'll be one of the nearly 50,000 young people to get a six-week job through the city's summer youth employment program. He hopes to get the same job he had last summer cleaning streets at the state minimum wage of $8.75 an hour.
MONCADA: Having a job, it makes me feel, you know, exciting, you know, somewhat. I can put money - my own money in my pocket instead of asking my parents for money all the time.
GOETZ: He's one of the lucky ones. In this summer jobs program, demand way outstrips openings by nearly 3 to 1. And it's not just New York. Nationwide, only about 30 percent of teens will work this summer. That's slightly up from recent years but way down from 2000 when 52 percent of teens worked. One reason for the steep drop is stiffer competition. Professor Ruth Milkman is a labor expert at the City University of New York.
RUTH MILKMAN: So it used to be that minimum-wage jobs were mostly for very young people, either teenagers or people just entering the labor market permanently. And what's happened with the deterioration of the wage structure in recent decades is that now more and more working adults are in minimum-wage jobs.
GOETZ: Drexel University recently looked at this. Ishwar Khatiwada is one of the study’s authors. He says teens are losing out in the battle for minimum-wage jobs, and that's a bad omen for the economy.
ISHWAR KHATIWADA: The more teens work today, they're more likely they will work tomorrow.
GOETZ: And, Khatiwada says, early job experience teaches them valuable skills that help later on. And there's more.
KHATIWADA: Evidence showed that teens, particularly from poor families, who work in summer are more likely to work part time after summer, are more likely persist and finish high school and more likely to enroll in college and graduate.
GOETZ: Yet only 20 percent of teens from households making less than $20,000 a year actually get summer jobs. In families making more than 100,000 a year, about 40 percent of teens work according to the study. One reason richer kids get jobs...
(SOUNDBITE OF CAR IGNITION)
GOETZ: They're more likely to have a car to get to work. And they're more likely to have parents with personal connections to people who do the hiring. Back at the jobs enrollment event, Jose Moncada says that with his summer job, he'll be able to buy his school uniform and sneakers. But with only one parent working, his family of six survives on less than $30,000 a year. Moncada says some of his paycheck goes to helping out.
MONCADA: Always, I, you know, go to the store and get the food that we need for the house, such as milk, cereal...
GOETZ: And that makes him feel good. He also has his sights on a future medical career. With his summer job, he's one step closer to that. For NPR News, I'm Kaomi Goetz in New York. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
300x250 Ad
300x250 Ad