Why Burundi Is Kicking Out Aid Groups

For 26 years, Handicap International has not only been providing crutches, prosthetics and wheelchairs to people with disabilities in Burundi, it has also been a leading advocate for people with disabilities in the country. Much of its work has focused on helping people get physical therapy, accessible housing and jobs.

But all of that is over now.

HI has been ordered by the government to stop its work in Burundi in a dispute over ethnic quotas. The government is requiring all foreign aid groups to commit to having 60 percent of their local employees be Hutus and 40 percent Tutsis – the quota for government agencies. The government is also demanding that foreign charities provide staff lists specifically identifying employees by their ethnicity. Rather than comply, Handicap International (which just recently changed its name to Humanity & Inclusion) is laying off all 105 of its local employees, shutting down its operations and pulling out of the central African nation.

Two other organizations — human rights group Avocats Sans Frontières and a Belgian NGO called RCN Justice & Démocratie — have announced that they're also departing over the new requirements.

The operation of dozens of other international aid groups remains suspended in a country where three-quarters of the population lives in poverty.

The government initiative began on Sept. 27, when the head of Burundi's National Security Council, Gen. Silas Ntigurirwa, went on national television and said that foreign aid agencies were operating illegally in Burundi. "The National Security Council has decided to suspend all activities of these NGOs for a period of three months dating from October 1 to allow the institutions in charge of them to verify their compliance with the laws and rules in place," the general declared.

Burundi is adjacent to Rwanda. Like its neighbor, it has a population that's predominantly Hutu with a smaller Tutsi minority. The country fought a violent civil war from 1993 to 2005 that was intertwined with the Rwandan genocide and had ethnic tensions at its roots.

Last fall roughly 130 foreign aid groups were ordered to suspend their operations and reapply for permission to operate in the country. According to the government, 84 agencies had done so as of Jan. 1.

Other charities that refused to go along with the new rules regarding ethnic quotas were told they were not allowed to work in the country in any way. "We were clearly told that if we do not share the ethnic origin of all our employees then we are not allowed to start again our operations," says Dominique Delvigne, who oversees HI's operations in Burundi as the group's geographic director for the African Great Lakes region.

"We've never asked the staff to share their ethnic origin and we do not want to do it in this current context," he says.

Ethnicity is not something that's officially noted on identification cards in Burundi as it was in Rwanda before the 1994 genocide. Opponents of the new rules say it's not the role or responsibility of foreign NGOs to collect this information.

This clash between the government and foreign aid workers comes as tensions in the country have been escalating. Amnesty International says security forces routinely kill, abduct, torture and detain people. The economy is in a tailspin. Burundi posted negative economic growth for the last three years, according to the African Development Bank. In 2015, President Pierre Nkurunziza defied term limits and won a controversial third term. Last year, the Central African nation quit the International Criminal Court and ejected the BBC and VOA. Hundreds of thousands of refugees have fled since Nkurunziza's latest re-election.

"It's very important to remember that the government in Burundi has been using ethnicity any time it's cornered," says a Burundian named Terry who now lives in the United States. He asked that his last name not be used because he still has family in Burundi and is concerned they could be harassed if he criticizes the government. Terry says there's still a lot of ethnic tension in Burundi, and he worries how the information that NGOs are being asked to collect might eventually be used.

"It could be used to track people. It could be used to intimidate people," he says. "Or it could be used to kill or to identify people to be killed who are considered opponents."

The new rules also require foreign aid groups to deposit a certain percentage of their annual budget in Burundi's central bank — seen as a rather blatant attempt to give the government access to much-needed foreign currency.

In announcing the ethnic quotas for NGO staff, government officials said they are attempting to make sure that aid groups hire more Hutus, who traditionally have been underrepresented in some sectors.

At the time of the initial announcement of the new rules, a spokesman for the president also accused foreign NGOs of spreading homosexuality and attempting to destabilize Burundi. Some of the NGOs do "nothing," he said, accusing one unnamed group of passing out only three chickens over the course of three years.

Dozens of aid groups are still in negotiations with the government about their operating status in Burundi.

Dominique Delvigne of HI says the decree has had a huge impact not just on aid workers, but on the whole country.

"The effect of the suspension was immediate," he says. "We were not allowed anymore to work. We couldn't even go and work with our support staff in our offices. We really had to stop the activities."

Agencies running hospitals and schools were allowed to continue, but all the other groups had to close their doors. At least three aid workers who ignored the order were arrested.

"As you can understand it was a very hard decision to make," Delvigne says. But he says it was an important decision. The government's request for ethnic information on HI's employees was a "red line" he says they were not willing to cross.

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.