Home Health Workers Struggle For Better Pay And Health Insurance
Home health care workers Jasmine Almodovar (far right) and Artheta Peters (center) take part in a Cleveland rally for higher pay on Sept. 4.
Holly Dawson believes her job is a calling.
She is one of about 2 million home care workers in the country. The jobs come with long hours and low pay.
Each workday, Dawson drives through the Cleveland suburbs to help people take their medicines, bathe and do the dishes. She also takes time to lend a sympathetic ear.
George Grellinger, a former client of hers, has dementia. He recently fell down the back steps of his home. Dawson remains friends and regularly stops in to check on him. To remain living at home, Grellinger had to switch to an aide who is covered by his veterans' benefits.
When Dawson worked for him, Grellinger paid an agency $37 for two hours of her time each day. Dawson received $13 an hour, higher than the national average for home health aides. She had to pay her own taxes and health care benefits. Dawson says she can't remember the last time she could afford health insurance
Dawson says she has been a home health aide for 31 years. She has never done it for the money, rather to help people like Grellinger, she says.
But the conditions of home health work are leading many aides to seek better pay and benefits.
On an early September morning, home health workers held a rally in Cleveland. Jasmine Almodovar, 35, chants with the crowd: "We want change and we don't mean pennies!"
She says she earns $9.50 an hour, which is actually just above average for a home health worker in Ohio.
"We work really long hours, really hard work," she says. "A lot of us are barely home because if we don't go to work, we don't get time off. We don't get paid vacations. And some of us haven't had raises in years."
Almodovar says her last raise was four years ago. She makes about $21,000 a year so she makes too much to qualify for Medicaid, but paying for a plan on Ohio's federal exchange doesn't fit in her monthly budget.
"I don't have a retirement plan, I don't have life insurance, I don't have medical," she says. "Because by a government basis, I'm 90 percent above the poverty level — but I'm in poverty."
Home care workers are mostly women. More than half are women of color, and 1 in 5 are single mothers. A recent analysis by the Brookings Institution found that while the ranks of home health workers grew exponentially over the past decade, their earnings dropped when accounting for inflation, says Martha Ross a researcher at Brookings.
"People aren't shocked about a fast food worker not having health insurance," she says, "But someone who is in the health care sector providing necessary health care who does not have health insurance? Just on the face of it, it's wrong."
Under the Affordable Care Act, there are financial incentives for hospitals and doctors to keep patients healthy. Ross says home care workers should be considered – and compensated – as vital front-line personnel in reaching the new goals.
And the U.S. Labor Department says more than a million new home care workers will be needed in the next decade.
"They can contribute to better care," Ross says. "Down the line that can contribute to reduced costs through reduced hospitalizations or going back into a nursing home and over time you can take those savings and put them into increased earnings for that home care worker."
Home care workers are often trusted advisors for the patients, says Lisa Kristosik with the Visiting Nurses Association of Ohio.
"People get real confused about how to navigate the health care system," she says. "And they know because they've seen it. Because they're in the homes. And they are in the homes for hours on end."
This story is part of a reporting partnership with NPR, WCPN and Kaiser Health News.
9(MDE1MTIxMDg0MDE0MDQ3NTY3MzkzMzY1NA001))
Transcript
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
There are more than 2 million home healthcare workers in this country. That number continues to grow rapidly as more Baby Boomers need assistance. But the profession does not offer competitive pay and, ironically, most home care workers lack health benefits themselves. Sarah Jane Tribble of member station WCPN in Cleveland talked with some of them.
SARAH JANE TRIBBLE, BYLINE: Holly Dawson believes her job is a calling. Each day Dawson drives herself to several people's homes in the Cleveland suburbs. She manages their medications, help them with bathing, does the dishes and provides companionship.
HOLLY DAWSON: Hey George. I'm going to get you something to drink, OK?
GEORGE GRELLINGER: Like wine?
DAWSON: I think it's a little too early for wine.
TRIBBLE: Former client George Grellinger has dementia and recently fell down the back steps of his home. Dawson remains friends and regularly stops in to check on him.
GRELLINGER: Orange juice and orange juice.
DAWSON: OK, I'll be right back.
TRIBBLE: To remain living at home, Grellinger had to switch to an aide who is covered by his VA benefits. When Dawson did work for them, the Grellingers paid an agency $37 for two hours every day. Dawson took home $13 an hour from that - better than the average pay. And then she had to pay her own taxes and healthcare benefits. Dawson says she doesn't remember the last time she could afford health insurance, and that is pretty typical in the home health aide world.
UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTERS: (Chanting) We want change and we don't mean pennies.
TRIBBLE: During a recent labor rally in Cleveland, home health workers voiced their frustration with low wages and lack of benefits. Thirty-five year ol, Jasmine Almodovar earns $9.50 an hour, which is just above the average for a home health worker in Ohio.
JASMINE ALMODOVAR: We work really long hours, really hard work. A lot of us are barely home 'cause if we don't go to work, we don't get time off. We don't get paid vacations and some of us haven't had raises in years.
TRIBBLE: Almodovar says her last raise was four years ago and she makes about $21,000 a year, so she doesn't qualify for Medicaid. Paying for a plan on Ohio's federal exchange doesn't fit in her monthly budget.
ALMODOVAR: I don't have a retirement plan. I don't have life insurance, I don't have medical because by a government basis, I'm 90 percent above the poverty level, but I'm in poverty.
TRIBBLE: Home care workers are mostly women. More than half are woman of color, and 1 in 5 are single mothers. A recent analysis by the Brookings Institution found that while the ranks of home health workers grew exponentially over the past decade, their earnings dropped when accounting for inflation. Martha Ross is with Brookings.
MARTHA ROSS: People aren't shocked about fast food workers not having health insurance, but someone who is in the healthcare sector, providing necessary healthcare, who does not have health insurance just, on the face of it, is wrong.
TRIBBLE: Under federal health reform there are financial incentives for hospitals and doctors to keep patients healthy. Ross says home care workers should be considered and compensated as vital front-line personnel in reaching the new goals.
ROSS: They can contribute to better care. Down the line, that can contribute to reduced costs through reduced hospitalizations or going back into a nursing home. And over time, you can take those savings and put them into increased earnings for that home care worker.
TRIBBLE: And home care workers are often trusted advisers for the patients says Lisa Kristosik with the Visiting Nurses Association of Ohio.
LISA KRISTOSIK: People get real confused about how to navigate the health care system, and they know because I've seen it. They're in the homes, and they're in the homes for hours on end.
TRIBBLE: Back at George Grellinger's house, former home health aide and now friend Holly Dawson says she has been a home health aide for 31 years. She has never done it for the money, rather, to help people like George.
GRELLINGER: Knowing that I can play a part in making somebody's life better or I try to.
TRIBBLE: The U.S. Labor Department says more than a million new home care workers will be needed in the next decade. For NPR news, I'm Sarah Jane Tribble in Cleveland.
BLOCK: This story is part of a reporting partnership with NPR, member station WCPN and Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
300x250 Ad
300x250 Ad